The show was incredible. We were smiling, laughing, and clapping the entire time. And so was everyone else around us. After taking setting and title suggestions from the audience, our show ended up being called Ride 'Em Cowgirl, the more-than-slightly-risqué show set in a "house of ill repute" in the Wild West (which was apparently in Tennessee; the Brits may need to work on their geography a touch).
Other than that bit, the actors were absolutely brilliant, mixing in homages to Hamilton, Bollywood, Matilda, Wicked, A Little Night Music, and Aladdin. Throughout this, they somehow managed to spin up and then resolve a plot wherein Clara Bell, an up and coming young lady working at the Prancing Pony, a "house of ill repute" run by Josephine, falls in love with Brother Jeremiah, the town preacher, who also happens to be Josephine's ex-husband. Another important character was Rumor Mary, the town gossip, and trusted confidante of Brother Jeremiah. As you can imagine, hilarity ensued.
At the end, everyone ends up married (even Rumor Mary, to the Prancing Pony's bar tender), and they all remember that beautiful verse from the bible, 1 Ephesians chapter something or other, "Love is wonderful, so don't settle for less," which they all recited at the same time (think Ouija board). It was glorious.